Where to Order the Best Thanksgiving Pies in Phoenix

Pie is a staple to every Thanksgiving meal. That’s why we’ve rounded up a list of restaurants and bakeries in Phoenix that are offering their delicious, seasonal pies for pre-order and pick-up, so that all you have to do is sit down and enjoy them. Read on to find where and how you can order your Thanksgiving pies this holiday. 

Bear and the Honey Bakery

At Bear and the Honey Bakery, each pie is made with fresh and organic produce nestled inside a buttery flakey crust. Plus, most pies can be customized to be allergy conscious, so dietary restrictions don’t have to get in the way this Thanksgiving. Pies include the Debra Pie (an oatmeal cookie turned pie), Dutch caramel apple, brûlée pumpkin, chocolate banana cream, This Sh!T Is Bananas Cream Pie, Rad Razzleberry, bourbon walnut pecan, zesty lemon meringue and cherry almond orange. Pre-order your Thanksgiving pie here until the pies sell out. 

JL Patisserie

Enjoy a French spin on all the American classics at JL Patisserie, which is offering three Thanksgiving pies for pre-order, as well as bake-at-home cinnamon rolls and more. Pies include an apple streusel made with a shortbread pie crust, a layer of almond cream, spiced Granny Smith apple filling and crispy streusel topping; a pumpkin pie prepared with a classic shortbread pie crust filled with light pumpkin custard and finished with intense vanilla mascarpone cream; and a pecan pie with a french-imported butter classic shortbread pie crust, house caramelized pecan butter filling, pecans and sea salted caramel. Add a pint of vanilla ice cream for the ultimate holiday dessert. Pre-order here by Nov. 19 

La Grande Orange Bake Shop

Satisfy the cravings of the whole family with La Grande Orange Bake Shop’s 11-inch, deep-dish pies available to pre-order from the Thanksgiving dessert menu. Pies include Bourbon pecan, pumpkin, salted caramel apple, lemon meringue and key lime. Order online here by Friday, Nov. 10. 

Lux Coffee

Lux Coffee is offering their delicious pies baked with organic ingredients and an all-butter hand-rolled crust for pre-order this Thanksgiving. Choose from pecan, pumpkin, apple, cherry streusel and berry with the option to add whip. Place your order by Nov. 21 by calling or texting 602-361-8866 or messaging Lux Coffee on Instagram @lux_arizona

Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole

There’s a pie for everyone at Mamma Toledo’s this Thanksgiving. Pre-order yours here by Nov. 17 for pick-up on Nov. 21 or 22, so you don’t miss out on Mamma’s signature creations, which include apple, apple crumb, caramel apple, green chile apple crumb, pumpkin, vegan pumpkin, banana cream, coconut cream, chocolate cream, pecan, hard whiskey pecan, cherry, cherry crumb, brown sugar peach and brown sugar peach crumb.

Miracle Mile Deli

The Valley’s longtime sandwich shop, Miracle Mile Deli, is helping you out this Thanksgiving with pre-order specials, including six delicious whole pies for $22 each. Choose from pumpkin, pecan, lemon meringue, Boston Cream Coconut Meringue, apple and cherry. Call 602.776.0992 to place your order today as quantities are limited. 

Morning Squeeze

Squeezed for time over the holidays? The groovy breakfast and lunch spot Morning Squeeze has takeaway pies and quiches for Thanksgiving that will help you entertain before and after the big meal. Pre-brunch quiches include the Veggie Quiche with spinach, tomato and Feta cheese and a Bacon & Cheddar Quiche. Both are $20 each and come with reheating instructions. For a post-dinner dessert, Morning Squeeze is offering two classic pies available for takeaway, including a 9-inch Pumpkin Pie and Peanut Butter Pie for $20 each. Thanksgiving pies and quiches can be pre-ordered now until November 21 at any Squeeze location for pick up on Nov. 22.

Ollie Vaughn’s Kitchen & Bakery

The classics are always a great way to go, but if you’re looking to mix it up this year with one-of-a-kind desserts, be sure to order your Thanksgiving pie from Ollie Vaughn’s Kitchen & Bakery, which offers unique flavors, including wild blueberry buttermilk, fernet-branca and chocolate walnut, miso sweet potato with black sesame crust, pumpkin with candied pecans, gluten-free chihuacle chile chocolate mousse and bourbon pecan and oat, plus a side of whipped vanilla bean ice cream. Order online here by November 15 for pick-up between Nov. 21–23. 

One More Bite Bakery

Add fresh baked pies to your Thanksgiving table this year with One More Bite Bakery’s made-from-scratch pies using fresh and local ingredients. This year’s menu includes: apple crumble, apple, caramel Dutch apple, chocolate chess, cherry, banana cream, chocolate cream, coconut cream, mixed berry, pumpkin, pumpkin supreme, bourbon pecan and key lime, plus a party pack featuring an assortment of seasonal pies. Pre-order here by Nov. 11 for pick-up on Nov. 22 at Uptown Farmers Market and Desert Monks Brewery. 


Find the perfect pie for your Thanksgiving table at Piefection, which boasts 70 varieties of pie to choose from. Seasonal pies include harvest pumpkin, caramel apple, cranberry Arizona orange, apple pecan spiced cheesecake, apple nut crunch, cranberry apple crumb, pumpkin pecan spiced streusel and more. Order in store or call 480.218.7437.

SugarJam The Southern Kitchen

SugarJam The Southern Kitchen is back again with another seasonal menu of home-style cooking and deep-dish pies for your Thanksgiving table. Featuring natural and organic ingredients, this season’s pie line up includes apple, caramel apple, apple crumb, cherry, cherry crumb, southern sweet potato, SugarJam pumpkin, bourbon pecan, chocolate pecan, peach cobbler. All pre-orders must be placed online by Nov. 17 for pick-up on Nov. 22. 

Süss Pastries 

Süss Pastries is elevating the classics this season with two decadent pies available for pre-order until No. 17. The first is an apple pie crumble made with a flaky buttery pie crust that is filled with fall-spiced granny smith apples and topped with a mesquite streusel. The second, a pumpkin cream pie, is sure to make a statement at the table with a lightly browned butter graham crust that is layered with cranberry jam, pumpkin cream cheese mousse and topped with toasted marshmallow fluff. Order online here.

Sweet Republic

The local artisan ice cream shop is taking Thanksgiving to a whole new level with ice cream-filled pies available for pre-order in three seasonal flavors. Each nine-inch pie serves 6–8 people and features a honey waffle crust that is filled with 24 oz. of ice cream and then topped with whipped cream. 

Choose from a decadent Apple Pie featuring Granny Smith apples roasted in butter and brown sugar, a cinnamon and apple brandy sweet cream and chunks of pie crust folded into the ice cream; a Maple Pecan Pie featuring maple-infused ice cream with Arizona-grown pecans; and a Pumpkin Spice Pie featuring classic slow-cooked pumpkin with a festive blend of six spices blended into the ice cream. The last day for pre-orders is Nov. 19, but if you order by Nov. 12, you’ll get $3 off. Pickups take place Nov. 20–22. Click here to order online. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts